ARCHAEOLOGISTS have branded the government's £200m plans for a 2.1km tunnel under Stonehenge "inadequate", claiming it would bring "irreversible damage to the World Heritage site".
At the inquiry this week, representatives of many of Britain's most respected archaeological organisations echoed the National Trust's demands for a longer tunnel to remove traffic from a larger section of the world-famous beauty spot than the iconic stone circle.
"The proposed road severs the spatial plane, depriving visitors of the ability to experience its connectedness," said Susan Denyer, of the International Council on Monuments and Sites UK.
"Stonehenge was inscribed on the World Heritage list as an entity that has integrity.
"Some parts of the site cannot have greater value than others."
Speaking for the Council for British Archaeology, the Prehistoric Society and the Wiltshire Archaeological and Natural History Society, Brian Davison claimed the joint funding arrangement between the department of media, culture and sport and the Highways Agency for the 2.1km tunnel was a quick-fix solution.
"Our objections to the published scheme concern its long-term adverse effects on the Stonehenge World Heritage Site," he said.
"We are also concerned that the much-vaunted cross-departmental funding for the scheme could create an unwarranted and, in our view, dangerous precedent for the future, not just for heritage interests but for almost any other environmental issue.
"We view with horror the prospect, in the event of the scheme being implemented, that the biggest single visible monument in this 5,000-year-old landscape of world value will be an early 21st Century roadway, primarily designed to relieve traffic congestion, the benefits of which cannot be projected beyond 30 years."
Stonehenge expert Michael Parker-Pearson added: "The length of the proposed tunnel is not satisfactory because of its impact on particular elements of the World Heritage site, notably the group of burial mounds on King Barrow Ridge.
"The design for the road scheme also seriously compromises the setting of the burial mounds at Longbarrow Crossroads.
"Furthermore, the proposals represent a missed opportunity to reunite the now sundered Stonehenge Avenue.
"We consider that the construction of a long bored tunnel, either on the present line or on the green route, is the only acceptable solution.
"Only such a tunnel will preserve and present the World Heritage site as an intact and integrated landscape.
"Rather than execute the proposed scheme for a short tunnel, it would indeed be better to do nothing until it is possible to do better.
"The proposed works are an unhappy compromise that would produce an unsatisfactory outcome."h Post, said the $25 million contract for the US Army and Air Force was the largest single contract ever placed with Alloy Surfaces.
Chemring is an international leader in defensive countermeasures, signalling and training pyrotechnics and marine safety products.
The countermeasures division comprises Alloy Surfaces Company Inc and Kilgore Flares Company LLC in the US, and Chemring Countermeasures in the UK.
Chemring Group has also announced its preliminary results for the year ended October 31 2003.
Turnover of continuing operations is up 32 per cent to £112.3m (2002: £85m) and profit before tax is £12.1m (2002: £5.4m).
Basic earnings per ordinary share are 31.04 pence (2002: 14.16 pence) and dividend per ordinary share 7.4 pence (2002: 6.7 pence).
Ken Scobie, Chemring Group chairman, said: "This has been a very successful year for the group, principally due to significant growth in the sales and profitability of our three countermeasures business - Chemring Countermeasures, Alloy Surfaces and Kilgore.
"Last year I expressed my confidence in the growing demand for our countermeasures products.
"Our performance this year and current events in Iraq and Afghanistan have demonstrated clearly to the military the essential part we play in defeating ground-based missiles.
"This is having the anticipated effect on our order book and inquiries for the future, particularly in the United States.
"Our military pyrotechnics business, our marine business and our Australian operation are expected to make further progress this year.
"This, together with the continuing expansion of our countermeasures business, should lead to another year of excellent growth for the group."
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article