A TRANS councillor has said the newly-elected Police & Crime Commissioner has caused “significant alarm and distress” by his attack on trans-inclusive policies.
On Wednesday (September 8) PCC Philip Wilkinson published a statement backing his Surrey counterpart, Lisa Townsend’s attack on LGBTQ+ charity Stonewall’s trans inclusivity policy.
Wiltshire Councillor for Corsham Pickwick, Helen Belcher, said the implications of Mr Wilkinson’s statement made her and others feel “frightened”.
“It’s a really nasty and antagonistic statement, which he is trying to gloss over as being inclusive. And he’s being the exact opposite of inclusive,” she said.
“He used the phrase ‘biological men’, now, people who use that phrase are almost always those people who are campaigning to remove trans people’s existing rights.
“By using that phrase, most trans people will immediately know that he's talking about trans women, not men.
“He’s saying, effectively, that trans women should not be in women’s spaces and he specifically mentions women’s prisons and toilets.”
Cllr Belcher pointed out that trans women have been able to use women-only spaces legally for decades.
READ MORE: MP to walk 87 miles to raise funds for local nursery
“If I was to use a public toilet in Wiltshire and I was maliciously reported, what level of confidence could I now have in a police force that is ultimately accountable to him?” she continued.
Cllr Belcher wrote to Mr Wilkinson on Thursday morning asking for a meeting and received a response for a meeting on Monday lunchtime.
“He’s caused massive alarm and distress,” she said.
“A number of people have contacted me saying how frightened they are now because they are trans or because they have trans people in their families. A number of others have said to me how appalling his comments are.
“He needs to withdraw his statement, correct himself and apologise.
“I would want to meet with him rather than him simply withdrawing his statement because of the outrage.
“Under my reading of the Public Order Act he has caused alarm and distress, he has clearly and deliberately targeted a protected minority group.
“He needs to understand the impact of what he has done.”
READ MORE: Last chance to comment on appeal over Malmesbury educational covenant
Mr Wilkinson said: “I have said I would meet with Cllr Belcher and I look forward to discussing her concerns and hearing about how we can continue to support an inclusive society for all.”
Swindon and Wiltshire Pride, too, criticised the PCC over his comments.
In a statement on social media, the organisation said it publicly opposed the comments made by Mr Wilkinson.
“We strongly oppose his views on Stonewall, as well as his opinions on the trans community,” it said.
READ MORE: Appeal launched after extension plans rejected
“We want to ensure everyone feels safe to be who they are and we will continue to support everyone and provide help wherever possible.”
Following the backlash over his statement supporting Surrey PCC Lisa Townsend and his opinions on inclusivity in policing – Mr Wilkinson released a statement to say he was not opposed to the trans community.
My views since I voiced my support of a fellow Police and Crime Commissioner and criticised the narrow ideologies of some lobbying groups has been the subject of much debate.
— Philip Wilkinson: PCC Wiltshire and Swindon (@pwilkinson_pcc) September 10, 2021
I have made a statement of clarification.
Please read it all https://t.co/WqZLWiZhk1 pic.twitter.com/AMDUKyL65p
Mr Wilkinson added: “Treating every human being with due sensitivity and compassion – regardless of sex, gender or ethnicity – is vitally important to me.
“I want there to be a respected, and respectful, place in our society for all.
“I have been clear, I am not opposed to the trans community, or any other of our minority groups or those with protected characteristics, or taking away any hard-won rights.
“My view is that there will always be some who use their strength to intimidate those less strong, or to exploit any circumstances to intimidate or harm others. I will not support them.
“I will not support those who promote a narrow ideology and political agenda that is exclusive or divisive, and promotes intolerance of each other and every person’s right to have an opinion.
READ MORE: Plans for pools, road closures and more public notices from Wiltshire
“But I must be clear, the rights of one community must be carefully considered alongside all others.
“It is right that all of our society have an equal voice and one community should not drown out another, regardless of their viewpoint.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereLast Updated:
Report this comment Cancel